During my own job hunt, the applicant experience brought me nothing but frustration at every turn, being fed to mailing lists, handing over phone numbers only to start receiving endless marketing calls, and feeling over and over as though my time were being intentionally wasted. This time, I entered the process as an evaluator.
In early November, I spent a week doing a series of case studies across different frontline shift-work industries to try and gain some insight into their job application process, firstly, to evaluate the applicant experience, but also to interrogate the claim that is so often made: That right now it is difficult to find employees (in a British Chambers of Commerce survey this summer, 73% of firms trying to recruit reported difficulties, and adult social care alone has around 96,000 vacancies on any given day, about three times the rate in the wider economy).
The UK is currently in the process of introducing and updating a lot of legislation, much of it impacting the hiring process, the Data (Use and Access) Act, the 2025 Employment Rights Act, new legal precedents under the Equality Act - like the For Women Scotland ruling in April 2025 - all coming at a time when HR departments and small businesses everywhere are adopting AI technology in their workflows. Understandably, the changing requirements can complicate the process of writing a good application form, and in my study, I was surprised by the sheer volume of issues, at least 15 of the 20 had some kind of issue in the employer’s own form or advert, rising to 18 when considering the route taken to get to the application. Of the 20 applications, only 2 could be considered ‘clean’ as far as I could see. That’s an unexpected result.
I went through twenty applications, ten in care, four in retail, two in hospitality, four in logistics, stopping before a submission, and stopping every time I was obliged to sign up for an account or hand over any information, as I carry forward in my work, I add each application reviewed to the study pool.
Let’s start with how employers are losing applicants - right off the bat, 8 of 20 applications stopped dead as I was forced to sign up for an account, 9 if you count a job found through the job site Indeed - 40-45% - further still, googling ‘retail job’ or ‘care jobs’ or permutations of such would have Google bring up job aggregators and boards (Leisurejobs, StudySmarter) before site listings, meaning that applicants could have to sign up to a service twice before being allowed to continue with an application. This happened two times, bringing us up to 11 total signups required, or 55% of the applications. This is all needless friction, every case of an account or email sign-up during my own job hunt often added between five to ten minutes to an application (for me, a tech-native and able-bodied 27-year-old), in the current job market, where applicants are encouraged to be applying to jobs at incredible volumes, that adds up fast, that’s time spent not applying to the next job, and from the applicant’s side, each account made is another email handed out, another marketing post in the inbox, another mailing list to unsubscribe from. It starts to become a defensible idea - under that paradigm - for an applicant to simply “go next” as soon as they’re obliged to sign up to something, even when viewed purely as a time-saving measure.
The next issue is forced consent. Throughout the process, I would be occasionally obliged to accept a privacy policy in order to submit an application - these usually denoted collecting my data for defensibly legitimate purposes, but also often included clauses about sharing that data with third parties, thereby obliging me to go read those parties’ privacy policies in order to have a full understanding of what’s happening with my data - I have a legal background, and time to spare for a dedicated study - the average applicant does not, the average applicant has ten other tabs open with different job applications and dwindling savings. Being unable to apply without clicking on an “I accept” box in front of a privacy policy is not consent, you can’t consent to a privacy policy, it’s information the employer has to give you, so asking you to “accept” doesn’t count as consent, it also gives the impression you’ve agreed to everything in it. If the employer genuinely relies on consent, making it an unavoidable condition of applying means it can’t be considered “freely given”, which is the UK GDPR’s test. Seven of twenty applications had some sort of checkbox or privacy policy with this kind of barrier.
Next up, the ways the employers are filtering candidates out without even realising it. Even for the candidates that do see the process through, many qualified applicants will be filtered out before anyone’s even seen their application, often applicants that employers would rather have seen than not. For example, according to the BBC, one of my case studies, Cera (a tech-led home care provider), uses an AI phone interviewer in its process, which scores applicants out of 100. In this case, we’re looking at one of the most direct forms of automated hiring, where the first interview is with an AI that scores you before you interact with a human. Right off the bat, a report by Greenhouse (a hiring software company) says 38% of US jobseekers have walked away from a hiring process because it included an AI interview, with another 12% saying they would. That’s more than a third who’ve already walked away from at least one employer over it, a harsh filter. Other employers on the list had disclosures about automated filtering in their sign-up pages and privacy notices, and one had a summary at the end of the application which had automatically graded all the various categories of the application (good/lacking). Aside from the fact that these grades can discourage applicants from submitting at all, employers are introducing a level of opacity between them and applicants, and even human review may not be doing much. If reviewers only ever look at the “approved” pile, nobody checks the people turned away by the system, and those rejections are effectively automated. The ICO found the same problem when it looked at automated hiring this year (2026). Employers who described their tools as “decision support” were making solely automated decisions in practice, because there was nobody meaningfully reviewing the outcome. The ICO puts it that human involvement has to be active, “not just a token gesture or ‘rubber stamp’”. Since February, decisions like that come with legal duties: telling applicants, letting them add context to the process, having a human review the decision, and giving applicants a way to challenge it.
One may argue that this is entirely the point of the system, that it filters. Reducing an unmanageable amount of CVs down to something workable. But let me argue this: filters are imperfect, applicants may be plentiful but truly good ones are rare, every worthwhile applicant lost to a miscalibrated filter or distrust of AI interviews is an additional cost to the business, more time spent hiring, more time filtering, fewer options, always bad. We want the best person, the first time round. Filters don’t have to be sophisticated AI systems either, Indeed offers employers a form with questions that can be marked as “required”, which automatically files candidates who answer incorrectly under “Rejected”, and many employers have similar questions on their own forms, at least 5 of the 12 forms I could actually see (42%!) had some sort of specific question that could auto-disqualify a candidate that could arguably still do the job, for example, several of the care positions asked if the candidate owned a car, when the job only really requires access to one. It may seem preferable to make the distinction, but that narrower question has a cost, a survey this year by the Homecare Association (the home care trade body) quoted providers as saying 80% of their workers use their own vehicle to travel between visits, so that makes 20% or one in five that already get between visits without using their own vehicle. An “own car” question could screen out people like them. 20%! In a sector where being unable to drive is a massive recruitment barrier (57% of home care providers in a 2025 industry survey call it a significant recruitment barrier, and it’s topped the list two years running), there we have a filter that makes the sector’s biggest recruitment problem worse.
Finally, we move on to the questions that employers can get sued over. In total, I found 6 questions like this, on 5 of the 12 forms I could actually see (42%). And the principle of the issue is this: Stop asking for information you don't need yet. Every single risky question I found was only risky because it was either misplaced in the process (too early!) or needed to come with a disclaimer of necessity (don't ask for biological sex unless it's a genuine requirement for the job!).
The information you need and when you should ask for it.
| Information | Do you need it? | When to ask | What I saw | The risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Right to work | Yes: you must check it before someone starts | On the application, one question for everyone, such as "Will you need us to sponsor a visa?". Check documents for everyone you offer a job | Visa questions before shortlisting, worded so they catch people already free to work | Turning away someone free to work because of their visa is a discrimination risk, and tribunals can weigh the Home Office code. Skip the check and it's up to £60,000 per illegal worker. |
| Nationality or citizenship | No, not to shortlist: the right-to-work check covers what the law requires | Not on the application. If you monitor it, use a separate, anonymous form that decision-makers never see | Compulsory nationality and citizenship questions | It puts nationality in front of whoever shortlists, so if you reject someone, the question can put the burden on you to prove it played no part. Discrimination awards have no cap. |
| Sex | Only if the role genuinely needs one sex | State the requirement and the reason in the advert. Otherwise, monitoring form only | A compulsory "biological sex" question with no requirement stated, and one advert that stated its requirement openly | With no stated requirement, anyone turned down can point to it as evidence of sex discrimination, and it's a gender reassignment risk for trans applicants. A stated, justified requirement protects you. |
| Criminal record | Depends on the role | After shortlisting or at offer, worded for the role, saying what applicants don't have to disclose | Tick-box bars, "Have you been charged with any crime?" and "regardless of date or country" | Ask for more than the role allows (spent records for most jobs, filtered ones for care) and you're holding data you're not entitled to, which can mean an ICO complaint or a compensation claim. Even a lawful tick-box bar loses you people before anyone looks. |
Right to work is the one thing you need from everyone, and understandably, businesses want to get it out of the way first. Getting it wrong is expensive: skip the check and employ someone who can't legally work here, and the penalty is up to £60,000 per worker. But the law only needs that check before someone starts, and the Home Office code says to ask about immigration status only where it's necessary, and to treat everyone the same, British citizens included. So what does that mean? If a group asks "Do you rely on a work visa to work in the UK?" (as one care home group does), that flags people who'd need sponsorship, but also graduates, dependants, refugees and BN(O) holders, whose visa or status already lets them work. All of them would simply be flagged as "needs visa". Admittedly, since July 2025, care providers can't sponsor new care workers from overseas, so asking about sponsorship is fair, but be specific to exactly that: "Will you need us to sponsor a visa?" Better yet, say it in the advert and let the check do the rest.
Nationality is where too early turns into risky. Two employers in my study made it compulsory before shortlisting: a Bristol care home group asks for your nationality, and Flying Tiger, the Danish variety store chain, asks for your citizenship. Neither needs it. The right-to-work check, done later and the same way for everyone, covers what the law requires. What the question does is put nationality, which counts as race under the Equality Act, in front of whoever's shortlisting. So turn someone down and they can claim discrimination, even though they never worked for you, and the fact that you asked that question can put the burden on you to prove nationality played no part. To know who's applying, use what ACAS recommends: a separate, anonymous monitoring form nobody involved in hiring sees.
Sex is the clearest case of a question that needs a reason attached. Since the For Women Scotland ruling in April 2025, "sex" in the Equality Act means biological sex. Choosing who to hire by sex is direct discrimination unless the job genuinely needs one sex (an "occupational requirement") and relying on it is proportionate. In home care there's often a real reason, like clients who want a female carer for personal care, and BelleVie, a home care provider, handles it well: its advert says "a female support worker is required" and calls it a "justified occupational requirement". Cera's application on Indeed, by contrast, makes "What is your biological sex?" compulsory, with no requirement stated in the ad. So anyone turned down can point to that question as evidence sex played a part, and asking everyone is a gender reassignment risk too. If the job needs it, say so in the advert. If it doesn't, it belongs on the monitoring form.
Criminal records are where the rules get technical, and the forms show it. For most jobs, you can only ask about unspent convictions. Most care work is exempt from the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act, so you can ask about spent ones too, but not "filtered" (protected) ones, and your question should say so. Ask for more and you're holding data you've no right to, which applicants can take to the ICO. Three care employers in my study handled it three different ways, none of them good. Helping Hands, a national home care provider, asks for every caution, conviction and motoring offence "regardless of date or country", or "your application may be withdrawn", which takes in filtered records too. The care home group that asked for nationality asks "Have you been charged with any crime?" (which also catches charges that were dropped), wants full details, and only then explains that some records are protected, so people can disclose them before they find out they don't have to. And one care group has three compulsory "agree you have no…" tick-boxes. That's lawful, but it stops anyone with even a minor record before a person ever looks. JD Sports, the sportswear retailer, shows how it's done: criminal record checks only after an offer is accepted, and only where they're relevant.
It isn't all bad news, and the good examples show how little it takes. Home Instead (a home care franchise) asks about vehicle access, commute and availability without shutting anyone out. Cosy Club (the bar and restaurant chain) needs no account, makes the CV optional and lets you tick the days you can work, rather than demanding full availability. DPD (the parcel delivery firm) takes warehouse applicants straight to a short form, with the pay and site address on show. And JD Sports keeps equality data separate and optional, and checks criminal records only after an offer.
Which brings me back to the claim I started with: that it's hard to find staff. In my study, the process itself was often what turned them away. Only 2 of the 20 applications were clean, as far as I could see. More than half made people sign up for something before they could apply, at least 5 of the 12 forms I could see could screen out someone who could do the job, and 5 asked at least one question an employer could be sued over. Each of those is a good applicant who goes next, and a vacancy that stays open longer, with more advertising, more agency shifts and more of a manager's time. We want the best person, the first time round, and most of what's in the way is the form.
The fixes are mostly free:
- Show the questions before asking anyone to sign up, and drop the account if you can.
- Link your privacy notice instead of making people "agree" to it.
- Make anything the job doesn't truly need "preferred", not "required", and ask about access to a car, not owning one.
- Ask one sponsorship question at most, and leave right-to-work documents and criminal records until the offer.
- Put nationality and sex on a separate, anonymous monitoring form, unless the job genuinely needs one sex and the advert says so.
- Look at who your system turns away, not just the pile it passes to you.
Problems like these are hard to spot from the inside, because you only ever see the applications that make it through. So, would you know if your form was doing any of this? That's what my hiring mystery shop is for: with your permission, I go through your application process as a test candidate, across your roles, and tell you what I find.